|
Post by joewiggs on Sept 26, 2010 10:47:20 GMT -5
Brave Bear (March 8, 1906):
Brave bear gives a rather startling ang graphic picture of his perspective concerning the beginning of the battle of the Little Big Horn. He says that , "I was with a party that had just returned with lots of plunder. War societies all through the villages were having scalp dances all night."
There is much more testimony given by other Native Americans that describe social dances occurring as well as "scalp" celebrations. It appears that a great deal of festive celebration took place well into the night until the break of dawn. As such, many warriors were in fact sleeping at the approach of Reno and Custer. Martini's exclamnation of Custer alleging that he caught then "sleeping" appers to have some merit after all.
In addition, the allegations of the village concealing themselves in orde to spring an inscrutable ambush upon the unsuspecting soldiers appears to be so much hog-wash. While it is true thast several Indians did manage to give oral shouts just prior to the arrival of the calvary, for the most part, the village erupted into chaos during the initial moments of the battle.
Brave Bear further states, "Two Crow Scouts of Custer came charging towards me." I believe this may be a referral to the wounding of White Swan on the east side of the river as Brave Bear alludes to the panic crossing of the "water" by Reno's men.
|
|
|
Post by Cutter on Sept 26, 2010 19:32:04 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by joewiggs on Oct 2, 2010 18:31:00 GMT -5
Thanks Cutter, glad to be back! you are so right! Reading the Indian narratives bring a human touch to the volumes and volumes of testimony existing regarding this battle. Because we have no "white" testimony about the demise of Custer and his men, the voices of the Native American speaks forcibly about the forces on both sides.
Little Soldier: "The discharge of black powder made the whole battlefield dark and gray. It was so dark that we could see the flash of the rifles. Some of Custer's men got into draws and coulees and fought there. From time to time Custer moved his flag from hill to hill. The Cheyenne and Sioux were soon all mixed in together in the fight. The Indian took after a man who was running back. Lots of horses were wounded."
These words from one who was actually there are gripping. One can easily imagine the fear, anxiety, and terror all of these men experienced as they fought for their very lives.
|
|
|
Post by joewiggs on Oct 9, 2010 16:04:14 GMT -5
The one factor about "testimonies" I have never understood is the insistence (by some) that Indian testimony must be disregarded. Let me immediately interject that no one on this board has voiced such an opinion. My confusion comes from the testimony at the Inquiry from "white" soldiers that was contradicting, bewildering, and so fraught with inconsistencies that the truth has been submerged in a bottomless pit of confusion forever;so it seems
I have argued with two nimshi boneheads (on another site) who are incapable of distinguishing the difference between legal testimony and simple testimony wherein legal ramifications are not required.
Indian testimony is no better or less than the testimony of most of the involved soldiers.
|
|